a basic question on good or desirable movements....i'd like to get some different opinions

Feb 16, 2010,19:24 PM
 

It's been a while since I've posted here.....I'm sorry if someone has posted this a similar question before but what makes a desirable movement? I own some Panerai watches and it seems they're always making the same variations of the same watch "8-Day" etc with different movements. What would make one movement better than another given a watch is essentially in the same case. I know that if you go to some watch forums.... some posters make a big deal about the movement ....."oh....it's a Jaeger movement"

Aside from the complication of the movement

Is it aesthetics .... the way a movement looks?

Is it the manufacturer....i.e. Jaeger movement versus "Panerai in-house movement"

Is it the age of the movement .... how long it's been manufactured?

Is it the name?

Or is it how well the movement is designed, (longevity)?

After all, some ETA movements have been around for quite sometime, are reliable timekeepers and yet they don't seem to be on many expensive watches.

I'm quite wondering how people feel about this in their collections?

Your thoughts?

Thanks!

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

It depends...

 
 By: brandon1 : February 16th, 2010-22:14
I think it really depends... For a watch for collecting, I'd say major important characteristics include, but are not limited to, rarity, exclusivity, aesthetic finish (anglage, etc), technical features (regulation system, power reserve, hacking etc) and ... 

No mention of accuracy?

 
 By: BDLJ : February 17th, 2010-15:15
I am probably reading too much into your response, but I didn't see accuracy amongst the desirable characteristics of a movement... An omission or is it a just a given? (!)

I just assumed it a given...

 
 By: brandon1 : February 17th, 2010-15:30
Since keeping time is the main function of the watch movement. I should have mentioned it none the less, thanks for pointing that out! B

You should be so lucky.

 
 By: mkvc : February 17th, 2010-22:29
Experience has shown that it is much harder to make a reliable, accurate movement than it is to make a well-decorated one.

I agree and...

 
 By: radone : February 18th, 2010-11:14
...that probably makes doing both incredibly difficult. I can name Lange & Sohne from the big league of producers and, of course, some small manufacturers like Voutilainen and Dufour.